IndyStar published the story here: https://www.indystar.com/story/news/2023/01/11/jared-olivetti-former-pastor-at-immanuel-reformed-presbyterian-church-now-faces-lawsuit/69797923007/
This is really intriguing. It appears to be a lawsuit on behalf of a child who was molested by the perpetrator. The lawsuit alleges that the Olivettis knew the perpetrator was molesting children, but still allowed the two to play together without notifying the parents or supervising. They also allegedly failed to report to the police.
The IRPC link is pretty obvious as well. If IRPC had reported, the child would potentially have been protected. Also, according to the Presbytery commission report, IRPC agreed (decided in a Session meeting?) that the perpetrator should not be allowed around children unsupervised, but that the elders failed to implement that plan.
The Synod link is much more interesting, legally. From a money perspective, very little is held by the Olivettis and IRPC, unless they have insurance coverage. Synod, on the other hand, owns all of the church properties in the denomination, so they are an obvious target. The question, then, is whether Synod is legally liable. At first blush it would seem not, but, did Synod and the Presbytery create a culture where churches could cover up things like child abuse knowing there would be no oversight or repercussions. If that is the case, could they be held liable for allowing such a culture to pervade the church courts.
I have reason to believe that the RP "good ole' boy network" will come back to bite them. Cross-referencing the IRPC Session minutes with the Presbytery minutes, there might be good evidence that Presbytery did not exercise proper oversight - enough to make a case that they are financially liable for the costs to this family.
8 comments:
The "created a culture of enablement" approach is an interesting one, but the plaintiff's lawyers seem not to have gone for it in their first punch. The complaint as written only alleges negligence against Immanuel and against the Synod (2 counts out of a total of 5).
The main points of argument seem to be fairly standard for that sort of a case:
"32. [All defendants] knew for months and potentially years before January 2021...that [abuser] had committed acts of sexual abuse against [plaintiff]."
"34. [All defendants] had a duty to implement policies and procedures to keep children who were likely to be exposed to [abuser] safe and Defendants either failed to implement ... or ... failed to enforce any such policies and procedures."
"35. Pursuant to I.C. 31-33-5-1, each of these defendants also had a legal obligation to report the abuse to the authorities. Not only did they fail to do so in a timely manner, but they also never disclosed to parents of children who continued to play unsupervised with [abuser]."
"36. [All defendants'] failure to warn [plaintiff's parents] of [abuser's] proclivity to sexually abuse children was negligent and as a direct and proximate result of such negligence, [plaintiff] has suffered physical damage and severe emotional damages."
As written, it's hard to see how to make this case stick against the Synod. Even the policy-making argument is a stretch, and the policy-enforcing one seems very weak: the presbyterian court of first instance for shepherding and disciplining individual members is typically the session. I understand going for the cash source as a strategic move, but the Synod's very late awareness of the matter (unless as a result of willful ignorance, which doesn't seem to be the case) is extremely unhelpful to the plaintiff. Unless there's some quirk of Indiana law not mentioned in the suit, the defendants' duty to warn and report would only kick in when the defendants knew or should have known about the abuse. Naming the presbytery as a defendant might have been a stronger legal (though not necessarily financial) option, since it was seized of the matter long before the Synod was.
But either way, as you noted, this looks to make Immanuel's exposure markedly larger, even while their ability to pay is markedly smaller -- and the Olivettis' exposure larger still, which is presumably why they're named in all 5 counts.
Olivettis' current deadline for a response to the complaint is February 10. The Synod's is February 26. Immanuel doesn't currently have counsel listed, so they haven't asked for an extension like the other defendants did. Nor have they actually filed anything.
Also, came across a podcast episode of Shaunestte Terrell, one of the plaintiff's named counsel, interviewing/conversing with Boz Tchividjian.
https://www.cohenandmalad.com/podcast-sexual-abuse/sexual-abuse-within-faith-communities/
They start referring to the Immanuel case at 17:50 and discuss it in generalities for about 10 minutes or so.
(As always, if this was already published here and I've missed/forgotten it, apologies for the duplication.)
I'm wondering whether the Presbytery is separately incorporated or if it is legally part of the Synod. That would explain why the Presbytery wasn't named separately.
are pastors protected when they’re kids get into trouble with the law, too? isn’t their a bible verse about elders needing to be in charge of their homes? kids are growing and no one is perfect, so i have no judgment on that. the issue is pastors are hiding huge issues at home and putting on a different family face at church.
It really depends. I think as with all tribes, there is an inherent tendency to protect tribal leaders because they represent the tribe publicly, but when there is a certain level of public scrutiny, those tribal leaders are going to lose their protection to save the reputation of the tribe. If I were IndyStar, that is what I would be trying to dig into.
So, if member Joe has a problem with pastor Frank, the session will almost certainly defend pastor Frank unless the charges are strong and obvious. If there is any way to reinterpret the situation in Frank's favor, they will do so. The presbytery will do the same with the session. Maybe if the session's treatment of Joe rises to some level of obvious abuse or doctrinal error, the presbytery will intervene, but usually not.
A pastor's handling of his family is mostly going to be ignored. What forced Synod's hand in the Olivetti matter was the media attention, and that Jared was obviously using his authority to silence victims, avoid accountability for his family member, and avoid outside scrutiny.
There's a book by former pastor Norman Carson, "Precious Son". Carson's son came out as gay and was excommunicated. The book talks about the public excommunication being a punishment for Norman because the son had no involvement in the church at that point. Carson, however, was not separately charged (and I don't think he should have been) for his wayward son.
If a pastors son breaks the law and is arrested, that does mean the pastor doesn’t have control over his home. Hiring a lawyer and having the charge expunged fast as lightning doesn’t remove that it happened. I think it’s good to give the young person involved a clean slate and help him get better, but I fear certain pastors motivation is protecting themselves and their position and income, and it’s a real conundrum when a son is expunged more quickly than usually occurs in general legal timetables, but other people in need are neglected and told with a fake smile, while suffering abuse, that ‘the RP process just moves slow.’ There are serious mental health issues being suffered by some of the youth and young adults in churches in general. Some elders and pastors are seriously struggling with sin and ‘functional mental illness’ (ex: sociopathy, etc.). As for the O case, no one is asking the real question: why didn’t he at least get his son private help? And I’ll ask a statistical question: what percentage of boys who are abused have first been sexually abused by a male relative?
Even more troubling because I think he and/or his wife are certified Biblical counselors. I'm not thrilled with Biblical counseling, but they should certainly be trained on when to escalate to licensed mental health professionals. They probably thought it would be shameful to do so.
I think it's difficult to make a blanket statement that any parent is disqualified whose child commits a felony, but I would agree in this case that the parents chose their reputation and actively covered up their child's actions instead of proactively seeking help for him and his victims.
I don’t think it was just about reputation, I think it was more. Skirt around it if you will (‘you’ being anyone). It was possible to get care that was private without anyone finding out. Determined people are nothing if not resourceful. So that then leaves the only fear beyond the church knowing-what the boy might reveal under counselling.
Post a Comment